Leading expert in social determinants of health, Dr. George Kaplan, MD, explains how poor health choices like smoking, poor diet, and physical inactivity are not simply matters of free will but are powerfully shaped by social pressures, environmental conditions, and economic factors. He details how access to healthy food, job demands, and targeted advertising create patterns of behavior that are tied to neighborhoods and income levels, not individual failings, emphasizing that changing the environment is key to improving population health outcomes.
More from Public Health
More from Diagnostic Detectives Network
Social and Environmental Factors Behind Poor Health Choices
Jump To Section
- Beyond Individual Choice
- Neighborhood Access to Food
- Income Barriers to Healthy Eating
- Job Demands and Physical Activity
- Impact of Advertising Patterns
- Environmental Influence on Behavior
- Importance of a Medical Second Opinion
Beyond Individual Choice
Common poor health choices like cigarette smoking, poor diet, and physical inactivity are often mislabeled as simple failures of individual willpower. Dr. George Kaplan, MD, argues that this perspective is fundamentally flawed. He states that while these behaviors are practiced by individuals, they are not purely a matter of free will.
Neighborhood Access to Food
A critical social factor influencing diet is a patient's physical environment. Dr. George Kaplan, MD, explains that people living in particular neighborhoods frequently have less access to certain kinds of healthy, fresh food. This creates a systemic barrier to making nutritious choices, regardless of an individual's personal desires or knowledge.
Income Barriers to Healthy Eating
Economic status is a powerful determinant of dietary quality. Dr. George Kaplan, MD, points out that patients with low incomes often only have access to high-calorie, calorie-dense foods because these options are inexpensive. This economic reality makes choosing healthy foods a significant challenge, shifting the focus from personal choice to systemic inequality.
Job Demands and Physical Activity
The nature of a person's work profoundly impacts their capacity for leisure-time physical activity. As Dr. George Kaplan, MD, notes, individuals who work at jobs that are repetitive and physically demanding are unlikely to have the energy to get on a bike and ride 50 miles after work. This reframes inactivity from a lazy choice to a consequence of occupational exhaustion.
Impact of Advertising Patterns
External social pressures, including targeted advertising patterns, have a major impact on health behaviors. Dr. George Kaplan, MD, includes marketing strategies as a key environmental factor that shapes consumer habits, often promoting unhealthy products like cigarettes and sugary drinks to vulnerable populations.
Environmental Influence on Behavior
The evidence shows that health behaviors are socially patterned. Dr. Kaplan provides a powerful insight: if you observe high rates of poor health choices in a specific area and then moved everybody out, a new group of patients moving in would likely show the same behavioral levels. This proves the problem is rooted in the environment and conditions under which patients live, not in the individuals themselves or a genetic propensity.
Importance of a Medical Second Opinion
Understanding these complex social determinants is crucial for effective healthcare. Dr. Anton Titov, MD, highlights that seeking a medical second opinion is important for patients. A comprehensive diagnosis and treatment plan must consider these broader life circumstances, not just the biological symptoms, to be truly effective and equitable.
Full Transcript
Dr. George Kaplan, MD: Cigarette smoking, poor diet, and physical inactivity are very commonly regarded as individual choices. But it is very hard for me to believe that these three factors are purely individual choices or free will.
That is an important insight on your part: while the behaviors are practiced by individuals, they are socially patterned. Patients who live in particular neighborhoods have less access to certain kinds of food. People who have low incomes may only have access to high-calorie, calorie-dense foods that are inexpensive.
People who work at jobs that are repetitive and physically demanding don't want to get on a bike and ride 50 miles after work. All these things, including advertising patterns, have an impact on the behaviors.
One way to think about it is that if you observe that these behaviors are higher in a particular area, suppose we moved everybody out of that area and substituted a new group of patients—they probably would also show the same levels of behavior.
It is not about the individuals. It is not about some genetic propensity. It is not about something that is written in stone. It is about the conditions under which these patients live.